Hello,
Please once check if you have made any Custom Layout for the Archive pages or not under the Dashboard > Layouts because if there is Custom layout enabled then this Theme Settings options won’t get precedence over that. Then the Layout options under the page builder editors take priority over them and things need to be changed or modified under the Layouts.
If you are unable to find yourself, then kindly please share your Site WP-ADMIN Login details in the Private Content field so that we can check this concern on your Site and help you out accordingly.
Best Regards