@cukebook Unfortunately, this may be a limitation of the Free version of the Wishlist plugin. If you look at the highlighted part of the image here, you will see 2 features in the Premium version that may be what you are looking for. BTW, the Premium version is 89.99 for single site use.
It means our theme does not influence the Wishlist functionality. It is just the way Wishlist works. If you want other features you can try to search for a plugin.
.
